They're overwhelmed and aren't even sure where to begin.
Some of the things they've done:
- Believing that their website had to have lots of content, their website has 5-10x more content than is probably needed, with 95% of the content accounting for only 5% of the page views.
- Believing that they weren't getting enough "shares" out of their site, they've added social sharing buttons for every network from BuzzFeed to Pinterest and everything other bookmarklet they could find, sometimes having multiple buttons on the same page in different formats, floating buttons, and popups/overlays.
- Reading that music and animations engage your visitors they've added both to their homepage resulting in bad elevator music and a Flash animation that takes forever to load.
- Having a hunch that nobody was finding their website from search engines they hired a SEO "expert" that made their site even more confusing and told them the only way to keep those "higher search results" was to pay them a monthly retainer.
Everything about your website should function as if your aim were to catch a mouse.
- How can you get the mice to your site,
- How can you encourage them to take the bait, and
- How can you snare them in your trap
To do this you must understand the mice (documenting the different types of mice you are trying to catch), determining which bait will entice each of the different types of mice (why are they at your site and what are they trying to find or do), and preparing your different traps, each trap being the action that you want those mice to take in your site (a purchase, a newsletter signup, a tell-your-friends, etc.). While some might say that getting people to your site is the objective, I disagree; getting them there is just 1/3 of the process, and a failure if you don't actually snare them.
With this in mind, take a look at your website. Using the mouse trapping strategy outlined above, how well does your site trap the mice? Is it a lean, mean, mouse-trapping machine? How much of your website is wasted pages and wasted screen real estate? How much of it is boring the mice or even driving them away in droves? It doesn't matter how big it is, how flashy it is, or even how much the President of the organization likes it.
If it doesn't catch the mice it's time to pull the plug.